Skip to main content

katrina

While some details of what came after the federal state of emergency can be disputed, the massive flooding as the result of oft predicted broken levees cannot be. Thousands drowned, many inch by inch over days spent trapped, finally giving into fatigue and the lack of upward mobility. Thousands were trapped in the convention center and the Superdome without food and water or working bathrooms. People died in the streets for lack of medication and proper care. I could go on, but what I realize is that I can only write about this in the most distant way. I can’t do justice to the horror of this situation, to the absolute depth of this sickening feeling of watching this disaster unfold over days, with seemingly no help coming; all the while being told to send money, I thought we should have sent people, buses, planes. It was like having to watch people trapped in the towers on 9/11 again, knowing that people are dying, minute by minute, but having those few hours stretched out over several days. Feeling powerless and just wanting the power to somehow save them. To be honest, I couldn’t watch it on television. I needed the emotionally sanitizing distance of the paper and the internet. It has still been overwhelming.

The thing that really blows me away is that the people with the power to save the trapped in New Orleans were somehow not getting the same reports that everyone else seemed to receive. Or perhaps more to the point, they just didn’t give a damn. I don’t want to go into all of my many problems with the President. It all pretty much boils down to one thing: he has failed at virtually everything that he has attempted. Bush didn’t deserve a second chance anymore than he deserved his first. Before the last election I asked several Republicans what he had done, factually, to deserve another four years. Aside from feelings and strong Kerry dislikes (which I understood) they had nothing that was “factually true.” I'd have accepted even dubious accomplishments. The fact is that since that morning in the midst of his first massive vacation, six months after starting his new job. When he received the memo warning that Osama wanted to fly planes into buildings; he has gotten away with things that would have led to impeachment hearings for a democrat or led a feeling man to break down crying, begging for forgiveness on national television.

I want him held accountable for his choices and general inability and unwillingness to govern. Whether you voted for him or not, unless you live in Florida, is this the man you want responsible for seeing to your well-being if disaster struck your home? I know enough about the aftermath of 9/11 to feel nervous about staying in NYC. So basically what I have done is collected bits from several blogs that I’ve been reading to provide some simple tools for discussing this national emergency and its widespread repercussions factually. Use this, critique it, let me know what i've missed or where I'm wrong. Eventually the post will have links to the articles and video where possible. In the meantime you can copy the web address and paste it in your browser window. Or paste the video into your windows media player. Crooksandliars.com has much of the video as .mov’s.

j
sept. 13

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

'Anti-racism', All Trap, No Honey: A Discourse About Discourse

One of the things that prevents me from writing more often is the sense that I'm just writing the same thing repeatedly from a slightly different angle. In a nutshell, all I'm saying is that moral idealism substituted for material goals will not lead to justice, but is an argument against materialism. I'm a dumb person's low rent Adolph Reed Jr. translator. I'm a "class reductionist" who understands that when the discourse is reduced to just class there's nothing as important as food, water and shelter that's left out. I often find myself contending with people who insist that there is, unable to name anything. They don't understand that they're making an argument against economic redistribution, or they don't care. There are no concrete manifestations of systemic racism or any oppression that are not dealt with through economic redistribution. When people say that economic redistribution won't end racism, what they mean is that

Anti-racism - Class = Status Quo: The Neoliberal Argument Against Coalition

I was approached a few months ago around the idea of collaborating to make the progressive case for reparations. I've said before that while the idea of reparations is morally appealing I don't believe in them as an immediate political project. It's not clear to me that it's possible to build a coalition around a reparative justice focused on just 13% of the population. Encouraged by a recent Twitter conversation that included economists Sandy Darrity and Darrick Hamilton where they suggested that saying reparations will never happen is cynical I've begun trying to think of them as an eventuality and lay out the steps to reaching them. Doing this has made clear that our understanding of reparations as a form of compensation to the descendants of the enslaved is not the reparative justice that we think it to be. If we were living with the kind of understanding of justice that made reparations possible we would not be a nation where war, healthcare, education, and cr

The Stories That Break Us, The Stories That Bind

Remember the mass shooter who planned and executed an attack on a gay nightclub in Orlando possibly because of his own unreconciled sexuality? It never happened. The mass shooting at The Pulse nightclub definitely happened, but the narrative around it was wrong from the start. I'm a poor consumer of mainstream news and still I was left with the erroneous impression that the sexual orientation of the victims was central to the event. It's understandable that even without consuming media one would conclude that this was an anti-gay hate crime. The victims were gay it happened in a gay nightclub. The story , like most of reality, is more complicated than the narratives we use to contain it. This illustrates the problem with a media more concerned with getting out the first just-so story that confirms our impressions and prejudices. It's worth pondering the ways in which this damages us. In the wake of the shooting, the media and public focused on certain details, many of which